Dora Award nominations: what they got right and wrong


Two powerful shows chronicling the Black experience head up the nominations for this year’s Dora Mavor Moore Awards, announced in a virtual ceremony this morning. The full list can be found here.

Soulpepper’s acclaimed production of The Brothers Size, Moonlight writer Tarell Alvin McCraney’s early play about two Louisiana brothers, received eight nominations, tied with Musical Stage Co. and Obsidian Theatre Co.’s excellent co-production of the civil-rights-era musical Caroline, Or Change.

Other lauded shows include Groundling Theatre Co. and Crow’s Theatre production of Julius Caesar, with seven nods; Soulpepper’s production of A Streetcar Named Desire, which got six; and Coal Mine Theatre’s intimate production of the sci-fi tinged play Marjorie Prime, which also received six.

Daren A. Herbert received nominations in two plays: outstanding performance in a leading role for Jesus Hopped The “A” Train, and performance in a featured role for The Brothers Size. And designer Ken MacKenzie received the most Dora nominations of anyone this season, with nods for Soulpepper’s Almighty Voice And His Wife, The Brothers Size (both scenic design) and Betrayal (costume design), and Howland Company’s Casimir And Caroline (costume design). 

Some snubs


Obsidian Theatre Co’s riveting production of Antoinette Nwandu’s urgent and timely play about systemic racism received a single nomination, for Alex McCooeye’s extraordinary featured performance, in which he played (among other things) a racist, violent cop. Too bad director Philip Akin and actors Kaleb Alexander and Mazin Elsadig weren’t acknowledged, although Elsadig did get recognized for The Brothers Size.


Although Anosh Irani’s play received deserved nominations for production, new play and performance in a lead role (for actor Anand Rajaram), Jason Hand’s exquisite, mood-shifting lighting and Thomas Ryder Payne’s suggestive sound design should have been acknowledged.


Allyson McMackon’s exquisite, way-outside-the-box production of Shakespeare’s comedy received four nominations – including best production and best performance by an ensemble – but it’s a shame McMackon wasn’t acknowledged as director, especially since this marks Theatre Rusticle’s final show and ranks among its best shows.


Considering how the pandemic has illustrated the deep flaws inherent in late-stage capitalism, it’s disappointing that the Dora jury found no love for Anthony MacMahon and Thomas McKechnie’s smart, challenging play about two overworked, underpaid Torontonians. 

Jon Kaplan Audience Choice Award 

Remember to vote for the award named after NOW’s beloved late stage writer. You can choose a show from the list of nominees for Outstanding Production, or choose something else you saw in theatre, dance or opera. Vote here from today through June 21 at midnight. The winner receives a special plaque from NOW Magazine presented by Jon’s husband, Don Cole. 

The Doras take place June 29 at 7:30 pm, and will stream live on the Dora Awards YouTube channel.  



Glenn started writing for NOW’s theatre section in 1997. Currently, he edits and contributes to the film and stage sections. He sees approximately 280 live stage shows and 150 movies a year. His mother once described his job as “Seeing The Lion King”

Read more by Glenn Sumi

June 8, 2020

6:18 PM